| icon | info | type |
|---|---|---|
 | The Original Gangster Obtained all Mafia: Definitive Edition Trophies |  Platinum |
 | A Chase through the Night Completed "An Offer You Can't Refuse" unlocked Jan 27th, 2025 9:06 pm |  Bronze |
 | The Back Streets of Little Italy Completed "Running Man" unlocked Jan 27th, 2025 9:18 pm | Bronze |
 | The Way this City Works Completed "Molotov Party" | Bronze |
 | Gangs of Lost Heaven Completed "Ordinary Routine" | Bronze |
 | Neighborhood Hero Completed "Fair Play" | Bronze |
 | Good Night for a Walk Anyways Completed "Sarah" | Bronze |
 | Storm Cloud over Chinatown Completed "Better Get Used to It" | Bronze |
 | Murder in the House of God Completed "The Saint and the Sinner" | Bronze |
 | Your Canuck Cousins Completed "A Trip to the Country" | Bronze |
 | Rat in the House Completed "Omerta" | Bronze |
 | Blood on Beech Hill Completed "Visiting Rich People" | Bronze |
 | Best Laid Plans Completed "Great Deal" | Bronze |
 | The Day the War Began Completed "Bon Appétit" | Bronze |
 | Death on the Water Completed "Happy Birthday" | Bronze |
 | When God Stops Smiling Completed "You Lucky ..." | Bronze |
 | The Day the War Ended Completed "Crème de la Crème" | Bronze |
 | A View from the Top Completed "Election Campaign" | Bronze |
 | Into the Lion's Den Completed "Just For Relaxation" | Bronze |
 | That Last Big Score Completed "Moonlighting" | Bronze |
 | Friends and Family Completed "The Death of Art" | Bronze |
 | A Life of Crime Completed the game on Easy, Medium, or Hard difficulty |  Gold |
 | Made Man Completed the game on Classic difficulty | Gold |
 | Supercharged Won the race |  Silver |
 | Lined Pockets Paid a fine to the Lost Heaven Police Department | Bronze |
 | Not Taken In Resisted arrest by the Lost Heaven Police Department | Bronze |
 | Heat from the Cops Lost the cops after accruing a five star police chase | Bronze |
 | Car Enthusiast Lockpicked 5 cars on the streets of Lost Heaven and environs | Bronze |
 | That Motor can Move Reached 50mph while driving the Bolt Ace | Bronze |
 | Stunt Rider Performed a wheelie for 3 seconds | Bronze |
 | Quite the Collection Collected 15 vehicles in the Garage | Bronze |
 | Motor Museum Collected 30 vehicles in the Garage | Silver |
 | Pulp Fiction Found a Pulp Magazine | Bronze |
 | Lending Library Found all Pulp Magazines | Silver |
 | Comic Violence Found a copy of Gangsters Monthly | Bronze |
 | Picture Book Connoisseur Found all copies of Gangsters Monthly | Silver |
 | Family History Found a 'Gangsters of the United States' cigarette card | Bronze |
 | Full Set Found all 'Gangsters of the United States' cigarette cards | Silver |
 | On the Trail Found a hidden car | Bronze |
 | Car Thief Number One Found all of the hidden cars | Silver |
 | Mystery Fox Discovered Found a Mystery Fox | Bronze |
 | Mystery Fox Domination Found all Mystery Foxes | Silver |
 | The Whole Story Completed the Collection | Gold |
 | Not Classy Took Paulie to a Place of Disrepute | Bronze |
