| icon | info | type |
|---|---|---|
 | Omnipotent Unlock all other trophies |  Platinum |
 | Born Again Finish the game |  Silver |
 | Sanctified Finish the game in Hard Mode |  Gold |
 | Preacher Finish the game in Nightmare Mode | Gold |
 | Saint Finish the game in Insane Mode | Gold |
 | Prophet Finish the game without hiding in a barrel or closet | Gold |
 | Messiah Finish the game in Insane Mode without reloading the camera battery | Gold |
 | Asahel Finish the game in under 4 hours | Silver |
 | What God Has Joined Find Lynn |  Bronze |
 | Babylon See the distant mines where Lynn is captive | Bronze |
 | Hang in there, Baby Escape the crucifixion | Bronze |
 | Be Thou Clean Escape from the Scalled | Silver |
 | Golgatha Reach the mine facility | Silver |
 | Sancti Sepulchri Descend into the mines | Silver |
 | Let No Man Put Asunder Reunited with Lynn | Silver |
 | Revelations Witness the end | Silver |
 | Bible Study Collect 40 documents | Silver |
 | Ordination Collect all documents | Gold |
 | The Road to Damascus Complete 30 recordings | Silver |
 | The Apostle Paul Complete all recordings | Gold |
 | Heal the Sick Use 10 bandages | Bronze |
 | Thoroughly Baptized Spend 10 minutes underwater | Bronze |
 | Them That Hath Ears Use the microphone for 20 minutes | Bronze |
 | Slip and Slide Perform a twelve-meter blood slide | Bronze |
 | Proper Penance Crawl for 500 meters | Bronze |
