| icon | info | gamerscore |
|---|---|---|
| Puzzling Master Completed all challenges | 20 | |
| Magic: The Puzzling Completed a challenge | 10 | |
| Devastator Dealt 20 combat damage to a player in a single turn in a game | 10 | |
| Life Preserver Increased your life total to 30 or more in single player, or 60 or more in Two-Headed Giant | 10 | |
| The Spark Won a game | 20 | |
| Epic Conclusion Defeated Tezzeret in the final single-player campaign battle | 40 | |
| Overflowing Harvest Put 8 lands onto the battlefield in one turn (Expansion 2) | 15 | |
| Planeswalker Unlocked 100% | 30 | |
| Master of Artifice Defeated Tezzeret the Seeker & Sarkan Vol in the cooperative campaign | 10 | |
| Everything at Stake Defeated Sorin Markov in the single-player campaign (Expansion 2) | 20 | |
| Puzzling Grandmaster Earned Puzzling Master and completed all Expansion 1 challenges | 15 | |
| Defender of Foriys Won a Two-Headed Giant game | 20 | |
| Dragon Slayer Defeated Nicol Bolas in the single player campaign (Expansion Pack 1) | 20 | |
| Overkill Controlled creatures with a total power of 75 or more (Expansion Pack 1) | 15 | |
| Duels Master Won 10 Xbox LIVE matches | 20 | |
| Duelist Won 5 ranked Xbox LIVE matches | 10 | |
| Spellslinger Defeated someone who has earned the Spellslinger achievement | 0 |
