| icon | info | gamerscore |
|---|---|---|
| Act I Completed Act I. | 30 | |
| Mayhem On chapter III, killed 20 armed enemies while riding the stagecoach. | 15 | |
| Frag Steal Killed all enemies in a single Cooperative Concentration Mode. | 10 | |
| None Shall Hide Shot an enemy through a wall. | 5 | |
| Welcome to the Frontier Finished a full Wild West Legends game. | 10 | |
| Catcher in the Rye On chapter II, killed enemy soldiers in the field using knives without being detected. | 15 | |
| D-Day On chapter I, destroyed all rafts before they landed. | 15 | |
| Forgiveth Me, Lord Killed 2000 enemies. | 50 | |
| Untouchable Finished a chapter, except for VI and VIII, without getting severly wounded. | 20 | |
| Mad Carpenter Killed 5 enemies with a chair. | 5 | |
| Vindicator Killed a total of 30 enemies with movable gatling. | 15 | |
| Man of the Hood On chapter XII, playing as Thomas, used only bow throughout the whole level. | 15 | |
| Between Hay and Grass Finished the game on at least medium difficulty. | 40 | |
| Ray's Story Finished every chapter playing as Ray. | 30 | |
| Crowbait Finished the game on at least easy difficulty. | 40 | |
| Act IV Completed Act IV. | 30 | |
| Rowing-Race Cheater On chapter XI, killed all the Indians during canoe chase. | 10 | |
| Rifle Expert Killed 250 People using rifles. | 25 | |
| Act III Completed Act III. | 30 | |
| Quite a Ride On chapter IX, destroyed everything that was thrown at the lift. | 15 | |
| Shield of Hope Finished all side quests. | 20 | |
| Act II Completed Act II. | 30 | |
| Boy Scout Finished one side quest. | 5 | |
| Drive-By Killed 5 enemies while horseback. | 15 | |
| 99 Scalps Delivered 99 headshots. | 25 | |
| Pistol Expert Killed 250 People using pistols. | 25 | |
| Arkansas Fried Rooster Blew up 10 chickens with dynamite. | 10 | |
| Sharpshooter Distraction On chapter IV, playing as Ray, killed sharpshooters without Thomas' help. | 15 | |
| Yankee Cow On chapter II, spared the cow. | 15 | |
| Unforgiven Killed 10 enemies as an invincible wanted. | 15 | |
| On the Right Track Collected a total of $200 000 and unlocked silver weapons in multiplayer. | 30 | |
| Thomas' Story Finished every chapter playing as Thomas. | 30 | |
| Gotta Catch'em All Collected all secrets. | 40 | |
| Sharpshooter Destruction On chapter IV, playing as Thomas, killed sharpshooters in 10 seconds. | 15 | |
| Well Invested Bought 20 second level and 10 third level upgrades. | 10 | |
| Crime Does Pay Won 5 rounds as an Outlaw. | 10 | |
| Quick Hands Killed 7 people during one concentration mode. | 10 | |
| High Noon Killed 4 enemies in high noon. | 5 | |
| Tin Star Won 5 rounds as a Lawman. | 10 | |
| Been There, Done That Played a full Wild West Legends game on every level. | 15 | |
| Curly Wolf Finished the game on hard difficulty. | 40 | |
| Fireworks Shot 2 enemy dynamite sticks in mid air. | 10 | |
| Shotgun Expert Killed 250 People using shotguns. | 25 |
