| icon | info | gamerscore |
|---|---|---|
| The Tally Complete all Arcade missions. | 20 | |
| Full Blast Kill a shotgunner with a close-range shotgun blast. | 10 | |
| That's How it Was Complete the Story on any difficulty. | 10 | |
| Violence Begets Violence Kill your lifetime nemesis honorably in a duel. | 20 | |
| Righteous Find and kill Jim Reed. | 10 | |
| Turkey Shoot Reach combo level of 20. | 20 | |
| Staying Afloat Discover a shipwreck in the Missouri swamps. | 10 | |
| True Story Find all Nuggets of Truth in a single mission. | 10 | |
| Death From Above Kill 5 enemies when falling down through the air. | 10 | |
| There's More to It Find and kill Johnny Ringo. | 10 | |
| For Massive Damage Shoot through a hole to kill an enemy that hides behind a shield. | 10 | |
| This Time for Real Give it to them straight about your meeting with Pat Garrett. | 10 | |
| Keep At It Unlock a skill. | 5 | |
| Perseverance Unlock both exclusive weapons in a single category of skills in Story Mode. | 15 | |
| Ungrateful Shoot a flying stick of dynamite and the one who threw it on a single Concentration. | 15 |
