| icon | info | gamerscore |
|---|---|---|
| Pocket Monster Stay in the pocket for at least 10 seconds. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no co-op) | 80 | |
| Orange Sherbet Anyone? Win an exhibition game with AFL presentation turned ON. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no co-op) | 30 | |
| Blast From The Past Win an AFL-themed Madden Moment with AFL presentation turned ON. | 30 | |
| Have to Be This Tall to Ride Stiff arm or juke Bob Sanders. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no Pro Bowl, no co-op) | 40 | |
| Mr. Not-So-Perfect Intercept a Tom Brady pass. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no Pro Bowl, no co-op) | 40 | |
| Buzzkill Intercept a pass intended for Randy Moss. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no Pro Bowl, no co-op) | 40 | |
| Nano Sack the QB before he can hand the ball off. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no co-op) | 50 | |
| Sprint 2 Minute Drill Win after being behind in the final 2 minutes of a game. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no co-op) | 30 | |
| Safety Inspection Required Create a team from Springfield. | 10 | |
| Mature Newbie Create a player or Superstar at the oldest possible age. | 10 | |
| Well played. Really. Throw the ball away on 4th down. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no co-op)
| 5 | |
| Fight for the Fumble Win possession of the ball after a fumble pile-up. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no co-op) | 30 | |
| Wounded Duck Complete a pass to an unintended receiver. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no co-op) | 50 | |
| Super Bowl MVP-like Catch a TD to take the lead with under 30 seconds left. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no co-op) | 50 | |
| Frozen Tundra Win at Lambeau Field in freezing weather. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no co-op) | 30 | |
| The Gang's All Here Trigger a gang tackle with 7+ players. 5 min qtrs, All Pro (no co-op)
| 50 |
